It is true that Harley showed quite correctly that the earth
curves approximately 8 inches in one mile. The solution presented then goes
on to find out over how many miles does the earth curve 72 inches or 6 feet.
Then this distance is doubled which is required (and would be easy to forget),
because each man looks this distance to his horizon, where the line of sight
is tangent to the earth's surface midway between them. All of this reasoning
is correct so far.
However, it turns out that while the earth does curve 8 inches in one mile,
it does not take 9 miles to curve 72 inches. To show this, let us return to
the Pythagorean Theorem method used by Harley, but using 6 feet for the curvature.
Here is a copy of Harley's diagram with
the 1 in the diagram replaced by x, since in this case the distance is unknown.
Again, using the theorem of Pythagoras
a2 = 39632 + x2 =
15705369 + x2
Solving for x,
x2 = a2 - 15705369
a must be 3963 miles + 6 feet (Let's say the men are actually
so their eyes are six feet above ground.). Thus
a = 3963.001136 miles
x2 = 15705378 - 15705369 = 9
x = 3 miles
Now, remember that each man looks 3 miles to the horizon, giving their distance
from each other as 6 miles.
This shows that at eye level of 6 ft. the horizon is 3 miles (at sea or
on a level plain).
A rule-of-thumb for line of sight problems such as this, where the distance
is small in comparison to the size of the earth is
c = (2/3) times x2, where x is distance in miles and c is curvature
For the problem at hand, we then have x2 = (3/2)c
x2 = (3/2) 6
x = 3
This is the same result that the more lengthy solution yielded.