SEARCH HOME
Math CentralQuandaries & Queries

search

Question from kim, a parent:

why can't a square number double another one

Do you mean why can't a square be twice another square?

Any integer can be broken down into a power of 2 times its 'odd part'. For example, 60 = 22 x 15, 1000 = 23 x 125, 37 =20 x 37, 38 = 21 x 19, etc. Thus if a square was twice another square, say m2 = 2xn2 let's think about the odd part of the numbers on each side of the equation. They must be the same and we can cancel them leaving just powers of 2 on both sides of the equation. Now comes a little bit of a subtle part. If we square an even number when we look at the result and break it into its odd part and powers of 2 the number of powers of two must be even; for example if we square 60 then the result is 24 x 152, if we square 37 we end up with 20 x 372, if we square 1000 we end up with 26 x 1252, etc. Thus if we had m2 = 2 x n2 the number of powers of 2 in m2 is even, likewise the number of powers of 2 in n2 is even but then we would have an even number of powers of 2 on the left hand side of the equation but (because of the extra 2) an odd number of powers of 2 on the right hand side of the equation and this can't be so as they're equal. Thus a square can't be twice another square

Hope this helps,

Penny

About Math Central
 

 


Math Central is supported by the University of Regina and The Pacific Institute for the Mathematical Sciences.
Quandaries & Queries page Home page University of Regina PIMS